• Skip to main content

Clay Whittington

Uncategorized

The Hymnal Is Not a Mandate: Patriotism, Christian Worship, and the Limits of Liturgical Appropriateness

November 13, 2026 by Clay

An examination of national songs in Christian hymnals through Scripture, theology, liturgical history, and musicology, with particular attention to the United Methodist and Episcopal traditions.


The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the positions or policies of Mount Tabor United Methodist Church, its clergy, staff, or leadership.


Introduction: When the Nation Enters the Sanctuary

Few subjects reveal the complicated relationship between American Christianity and national identity quite as clearly as the observance of patriotic holidays in Christian worship. Memorial Day, Independence Day, and Veterans Day routinely prompt questions among clergy, musicians, and worship planners about whether patriotic songs, military recognition, national symbols, or prayers for the nation belong within the Sunday morning liturgy.

These questions are particularly significant in traditions that understand Christian worship as something more than a gathering of religiously inclined citizens. In the historic liturgical traditions, worship is the assembled Church’s response to God’s revelation in Jesus Christ, expressed through proclamation, prayer, sacrament, and song. Its purpose is not primarily to affirm the cultural identity of the congregation, celebrate civic institutions, or reinforce national solidarity. Rather, Christian worship gathers a people whose fundamental allegiance is to the kingdom of God, a community that transcends political boundaries, national identities, and historical circumstances.

Nevertheless, American denominational hymnals frequently contain patriotic and national songs. The Untied Methodist Hymnal (1989), for example, includes both “My Country, ‘Tis of Thee” and “America the Beautiful.” The Episcopal Church’s The Hymnal 1982 contains the national anthems of both the United States and Canada, along with other hymns associated with national life and civic observances.

Their inclusion raises a legitimate question: Does the presence of a song in an authorized denominational hymnal establish its appropriateness for Christian worship?

The answer, I contend, is no.

A denominational hymnal is an important theological, historical, musical, and liturgical resource, but it is not an indiscriminate mandate for the use of every item it contains. Its contents reflect a variety of purposes, occasions, editorial decisions, and historical contexts. Some selections serve the central liturgies of the Church, while others are intended for particular services, devotional gatherings, civic observances, or pastoral circumstances. Still others preserve texts and musical traditions that deserve critical reconsideration as the Church’s theological understanding develops.

The more important question, therefore, is not simply whether a song appears in the hymnal, but whether its text, music, theological implications, and liturgical function are consistent with the nature and purpose of Christian worship.

This distinction is especially important when patriotic expression threatens to blur the boundary between devotion to God and allegiance to the nation.

1. The Biblical Distinction Between the Kingdom of God and the Nations

The theological problem of patriotic worship begins with a fundamental biblical distinction: the kingdom of God is not identical to any earthly nation.

Throughout Scripture, political authority is acknowledged as a legitimate, though limited, feature of human society. Governments may preserve order, administer justice, and contribute to the common good. Yet no earthly government possesses the ultimate authority, universal scope, or enduring character of God’s reign.

Render unto Caesar: The limits of political allegiance

In Matthew 22:15–22, the Pharisees and Herodians attempt to entrap Jesus with a question about paying taxes to the emperor. Jesus asks whose image and inscription appear on a coin. Upon receiving the answer, he responds:

“Give therefore to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s.” (Matthew 22:21, NRSVue)

This statement is frequently interpreted as an endorsement of the separation between religious and civil responsibilities. Such an interpretation is useful, though incomplete. Jesus does not establish two equal and independent spheres of authority. Instead, he distinguishes between the limited claims of imperial government and the ultimate claims of God.

The coin bears Caesar’s image, but human beings bear the image of God (Genesis 1:26–27). Thus, whatever obligations Christians may have toward political authorities remain subordinate to their more fundamental identity as creatures made in God’s image. This distinction has significant implications for Christian worship. The Church may recognize the legitimate work of government without incorporating the symbols, ceremonies, and celebrations of the state into its own liturgical identity.

Indeed, one might argue that maintaining this distinction is itself an expression of Christian faithfulness. By refusing to confuse political allegiance with religious devotion, the Church preserves its ability to speak prophetically to the nation, praising what is just and condemning what is unjust.

Christian citizenship and the heavenly commonwealth

Paul writes in Philippians 3:20:

“But our citizenship is in heaven, and it is from there that we are expecting a Savior, the Lord Jesus Christ.” (NRSVue)

Paul’s choice of language is deliberate. As a Roman colony, Philippi was a city whose inhabitants understood the privileges and responsibilities of Roman citizenship. By invoking the language of citizenship, Paul reminds the Philippians that their identity as Christians transcends earthly political allegiances. Their ultimate loyalty belongs not to Rome, but to Christ.

This does not mean that Christians must reject earthly citizenship or withdraw from civic life. Paul himself made use of his Roman citizenship (Acts 22:25–29). Rather, Christian identity establishes a hierarchy of allegiance in which national belonging is real but never ultimate.

The same principle appears in John 18:36, where Jesus tells Pilate:

“My kingdom is not from this world.” (NRSVue)

The distinction concerns the origin and character of Christ’s kingdom, not simply its geographical location. Jesus does not deny that his reign has implications for earthly life. Rather, he rejects the notion that his authority derives from the political and military mechanisms through which earthly kingdoms establish themselves.

Consequently, Christian worship should not present the nation as the embodiment of God’s kingdom or national success as evidence of divine favor.

The universal vision of the Church

One of the most compelling biblical arguments against nationalistic worship appears in Revelation 7:9, where John describes a multitude:

“from every nation, from all tribes and peoples and languages” (NRSVue)

This vision is profoundly international. The redeemed are not gathered according to their political loyalties, nor does one nation receive privileged status in the heavenly assembly.

Instead, people from every nation are united in worship before God. The Church’s earthly worship anticipates this heavenly reality. When Christians gather around Word and Table, they participate in a community whose membership is not determined by citizenship, ethnicity, language, or national origin.

This consideration carries added weight in the United States, where Christian congregations may include immigrants, refugees, international visitors, and others whose relationships with American political institutions vary widely.

A congregation may be geographically situated in the United States, but its worship is not the property of the United States. The Church worships as part of the universal body of Christ, not as the religious assembly of a particular nation.

Praying for the nation is not the same as worshiping the nation

Scripture does instruct Christians to pray for political leaders.

First Timothy 2:1–2 calls for prayers and intercessions for all people, including rulers and those in positions of authority. The purpose is not the glorification of government but the well-being of society and the possibility of peaceful, godly living.

Similarly, Jeremiah 29:7 instructs the exiles to seek the welfare of the city in which they have been placed. The significance of this passage lies in the city itself: Babylon, the capital of the empire responsible for Judah’s exile. The people of God are instructed to seek the welfare of a foreign political community without identifying that community with God’s covenant people.

Praying for the welfare of a nation, therefore, does not require celebrating its political institutions, endorsing its military activities, or asserting its exceptional status before God. Christians may pray for the United States just as they should pray for Canada, Mexico, Ukraine, Russia, Israel, Palestine, and every other nation. The theological distinction is not between praying for one’s country and refusing to pray for it. It is between praying for a nation under God’s judgment and mercy and treating that nation as an object of sacred devotion.

2. Christian Worship Is Not a Civic Ceremony

The nature and purpose of Christian worship bring the distinction between national and Christian identity into sharper focus. In the United Methodist tradition, the Sunday service is ordinarily organized around the movements of Entrance, Proclamation and Response, Thanksgiving and Communion, and Sending Forth. These movements articulate a theological narrative: God gathers the people, speaks through Scripture, receives their response, nourishes them through grace, and sends them into the world for Christian service. The structure is not simply a convenient sequence of activities. It expresses what the Church believes worship accomplishes.

Similarly, the Episcopal Church’s Book of Common Prayer (1979) orders its principal Sunday worship around the proclamation of the Word and the celebration of the Holy Eucharist.

In both traditions, the liturgy is fundamentally oriented toward God’s saving work in Jesus Christ.

A patriotic observance operates according to a different narrative. It may commemorate a nation’s founding, honor military service, celebrate political freedom, or recognize the sacrifices of citizens. These are legitimate subjects for civic remembrance, but they are not equivalent to the proclamation of the gospel.

The problem of competing narratives

Consider the difference between a Christian celebration of All Saints’ Day and a Veterans Day observance.

All Saints’ Day remembers the communion of saints and the hope of resurrection through Jesus Christ. Its theological center is the victory of Christ over death and the unity of the Church across time.

Veterans Day, by contrast, is a civic observance honoring those who have served in the United States Armed Forces. Its historical and cultural purposes are distinct from those of All Saints’ Day.

A congregation may include veterans whose service deserves genuine gratitude and respect. Yet transforming the Sunday liturgy into a celebration of military service introduces a second narrative that may compete with the Church’s proclamation.

This is not an argument against veterans, military families, or those who have sacrificed in service to others. Several men in my own family have served in the armed forces, and I hold tremendous respect and gratitude for their service and sacrifice. Nor am I suggesting that military service is inherently incompatible with Christian discipleship. Rather, I believe we must distinguish between honoring those who have served our country and allowing expressions of patriotism to shape the worship of the Church.

It is an argument about the proper object and purpose of worship.

A church may recognize veterans through a fellowship gathering, community reception, educational program, pastoral conversation, or other appropriate occasion without making military recognition a defining element of its Sunday liturgy.

Indeed, such a distinction may allow the Church to honor veterans more thoughtfully, including those whose experiences of military service involve grief, trauma, moral injury, or ambivalence rather than uncomplicated celebration.

The Christian calendar as a theological discipline

The Church’s liturgical calendar provides another important framework for this discussion. Advent, Christmas, Epiphany, Lent, Easter, Pentecost, and the Sundays of Ordinary Time organize Christian worship around the life, death, resurrection, and continuing presence of Jesus Christ. The calendar also includes commemorations of saints and other observances that bear witness to the history of Christian faith.

These occasions are not interchangeable with civic or commercial holidays.

Mother’s Day, Father’s Day, Independence Day, and Veterans Day may be meaningful within the cultural life of a congregation, but they do not thereby become feasts of the Christian Church. The distinction is not that secular occasions are unimportant. Rather, the Christian calendar exists precisely to form believers according to a theological understanding of time.

When the Church repeatedly substitutes civic anniversaries or commercial observances for the appointed themes of Christian worship, it risks allowing the surrounding culture to determine the content of its proclamation. This concern becomes particularly acute when a civic observance falls near a major Christian feast.

A Sunday near Veterans Day may also be a Sunday when the appointed Scriptures address the resurrection, the communion of saints, the judgment of God, or the coming reign of Christ. The Church must ask which narrative has the greater claim upon its worship. A congregation’s answer reveals something important about its understanding of Christian identity.

3. What Is a Hymnal, and What Does Its Inclusion Actually Mean?

One of the most persistent misconceptions in congregational music planning is the assumption that inclusion in a denominational hymnal constitutes an endorsement of a song for every worship setting. This misunderstands both the historical development and the practical function of hymnals.

A hymnal is not simply a collection of songs deemed appropriate for Sunday morning. It is a curated repository of congregational music, liturgical texts, devotional resources, and historical traditions intended to serve the varied needs of a particular religious community. The scope of a hymnal is necessarily broader than that of any single worship service.

Hymnals as historical and theological documents

Hymnals are products of particular historical moments. Their editorial committees make decisions based on theology, denominational identity, musical practice, cultural expectations, congregational familiarity, and the anticipated needs of worshiping communities.

These decisions may reflect careful theological discernment, but they are not infallible.

The United Methodist Hymnal was published in 1989, following the formation of The United Methodist Church in 1968. It reflects both the inheritance of earlier Methodist traditions and the liturgical and theological developments of the late twentieth century. Its publication was a significant accomplishment in denominational worship renewal. Nevertheless, its contents remain subject to the continuing theological reflection of the Church.

The mere fact that a hymn was included in 1989 does not establish that its language, assumptions, or theological emphases remain equally appropriate nearly four decades later. Indeed, the Church’s continuing engagement with questions of racial justice, gender, disability, ecumenism, colonialism, and interreligious relationships demonstrates that theological language and congregational practice are never beyond examination.

A hymnal may preserve texts that are historically important without requiring their continued use in every circumstance. There is a meaningful difference between preserving a hymn as part of a tradition’s musical inheritance and recommending it as an expression of the Church’s present theological convictions.

The hymnal as a resource for multiple forms of worship

The internal organization of the United Methodist Hymnal provides compelling evidence against the assumption that every selection is intended for ordinary Sunday worship.

For example, the hymnal includes a substantial collection of morning and evening hymns, such as “All Praise to Thee, My God, This Night” (UMH 682), “The Day Is Past and Over” (UMH 683), “O Gladsome Light” (UMH 686), “At the Close of Day” (UMH 689), and “The Day Thou Gavest, Lord, Is Ended” (UMH 690).

These works serve particular devotional and liturgical contexts.

“O Gladsome Light,” for instance, is a translation of the ancient Greek hymn Phos hilaron, traditionally associated with the lighting of lamps at evening prayer. Its inclusion in the hymnal preserves an important element of Christian liturgical history. Yet its presence does not suggest that every Sunday morning service should include an evening lamp-lighting hymn.

Such a selection might be entirely appropriate for Evensong, Vespers, an evening vigil, or a service structured around the imagery of Christ as light. Its use during a Sunday morning service would require a different liturgical justification.

The distinction is not between acceptable and unacceptable music in an absolute sense. It is between music appropriate to a particular liturgical occasion and music that may be inappropriate when removed from its intended context.

The Episcopal tradition offers an even more developed example. The Hymnal 1982 contains hymns and service music associated with Morning Prayer, Evening Prayer, the Holy Eucharist, and other liturgical occasions. It functions alongside The Book of Common Prayer, whose offices and rites determine the theological and structural context in which music is used.

A setting of the Magnificat may be especially appropriate at Evensong. A setting of the Nunc dimittis may serve the same office. Neither is thereby prohibited from appearing elsewhere, but their traditional placement reveals why the hymnal contains them.

The hymnal serves the liturgy; the liturgy does not exist to accommodate every selection in the hymnal.

Authorization is not obligation

A further distinction must be made between music that is authorized, music that is permitted, and music that is pastorally or theologically advisable. These categories are not identical.

The Episcopal Church’s General Convention authorized The Hymnal 1982 for use in the Church, a process documented in the proceedings of the 1982 General Convention. Such authorization establishes the collection as an approved ecclesiastical resource. It does not mean that every hymn is required, nor that each selection is equally suitable for every liturgical setting.

Similarly, The United Methodist Hymnal provides a recognized body of congregational music, but worship planners must still exercise judgment concerning the relationship between individual selections and the theology of the service.

This distinction is essential because a denominational hymnal is not a substitute for liturgical discernment. Its contents may provide options, but the responsibility for selecting those options remains with those entrusted with the planning and leadership of worship. The hymnal establishes a repertoire of possibilities, not an obligation to use every item it contains.

4. The Historical Development of National Songs in American Hymnals

The presence of patriotic songs in American hymnals did not emerge in a historical vacuum. It reflects the complicated relationship between Protestant Christianity, national identity, and American civic culture.

From the colonial period onward, many American Protestant communities understood religious liberty, republican government, and national independence through explicitly theological categories. For some, the founding of the United States represented an extraordinary act of divine providence. For others, the nation’s political institutions offered an opportunity to establish a society governed by Christian moral principles.

Such convictions contributed to the development of American civil religion, a concept famously explored by sociologist Robert N. Bellah in his 1967 essay, “Civil Religion in America.” Bellah argued that American public life had developed a set of religious symbols, narratives, and rituals that existed alongside, but were not identical to, the institutional traditions of Christianity.

Presidential inaugurations, national memorials, patriotic speeches, and public references to divine providence all contributed to a shared civic religious vocabulary. The danger for Christian worship arises when this civic vocabulary is absorbed into the Church’s liturgy without adequate theological distinction.

The American Protestant inheritance

During the nineteenth century, patriotic hymns became increasingly common in Protestant congregational life. Samuel Francis Smith wrote “My Country, ‘Tis of Thee” in 1831, and it was first publicly sung in 1832. Its familiar melody, AMERICA, was also associated with “God Save the King,” the British royal anthem.

The irony of this shared melody is difficult to overlook. A tune historically associated with British monarchy became a vehicle for celebrating American liberty and independence. Its musical identity took on an entirely different national significance through the attachment of a new text.

The same melody could serve different, even politically opposed, national narratives. This illustrates an important musicological principle: the cultural meaning of a tune is not inherent in its notes alone but is shaped by its text, historical associations, and performance context.

“My Country, ‘Tis of Thee” begins with an expression of national affection and proceeds toward an invocation of God as the source of liberty. Although its final stanza addresses God directly, much of the song celebrates the nation itself. Its theological content therefore differs from that of a hymn whose primary subject is God’s character, Christ’s saving work, or the Church’s response to divine grace.

Katharine Lee Bates’s “America the Beautiful” presents a somewhat different case. The text originated in 1893 and was revised in subsequent years, with the familiar 1904 version becoming widely established. Its melody, MATERNA, was composed by Samuel A. Ward in 1888 and later joined to Bates’s words. Unlike an entirely celebratory national song, “America the Beautiful” contains petitions for the moral improvement of the nation. Its third stanza, for example, asks God to correct the nation’s shortcomings and strengthen its commitment to liberty under law. Such language introduces an element of moral self-examination that complicates any simplistic dismissal of the text as nationalistic propaganda.

Nevertheless, the song remains geographically and politically particular. Its central subject is the United States, and its emotional power derives substantially from the beauty, history, and aspirations of that nation. This makes it a patriotic song with religious language rather than necessarily a hymn of Christian worship.

The editorial decisions of the United Methodist Hymnal

The United Methodist Hymnal includes “America the Beautiful” (UMH 696), “America (My Country, ’Tis of Thee)” (UMH 697), and “God of the Ages” (UMH 698). These appear within the hymnal’s material for special days and national observances. The presence of these works is historically significant, but the hymnal’s broader treatment of national themes deserves equal attention.

Dean McIntyre, writing for the Baltimore-Washington Conference of The United Methodist Church in 2014, examined the history of patriotic music in Methodist hymnals. He noted that the 1989 hymnal includes more national and patriotic selections than several of its twentieth-century Methodist predecessors.

He also identified a notable absence: neither “The Star-Spangled Banner” nor “God Bless America” had been included in the twentieth-century Methodist hymnals he surveyed.

His comparison demonstrates that patriotic repertoire has never been a fixed or inevitable feature of Methodist hymnody. Its contents have changed according to editorial decisions and historical circumstances.

Consequently, the inclusion or omission of a particular national song should not be treated as a definitive theological judgment. It is evidence of an editorial decision made at a particular moment in the Church’s history.

The Episcopal example

The Hymnal 1982 offers an especially useful comparison because of its relationship to the Episcopal Church’s liturgical tradition.

The hymnal includes national songs, including “The Star-Spangled Banner” and “O Canada,” alongside the Church’s extensive repertoire of psalms, canticles, hymns, and service music. The inclusion of both national anthems raises an important question about the relationship between a hymn’s presence in a denominational hymnal and its appropriateness for Christian worship. If the inclusion of the American national anthem made its performance obligatory or inherently appropriate for Sunday worship, the same logic would presumably apply to the Canadian anthem. Yet few American Episcopal congregations would consider the singing of “O Canada” an ordinary feature of Sunday Eucharist.

The distinction demonstrates that inclusion in a hymnal cannot, by itself, determine liturgical appropriateness. The national anthems exist within a broader repertoire intended to meet varied pastoral, ecclesiastical, and civic needs.

The Episcopal Church’s Book of Common Prayer also provides prayers for national life, including prayers for the country, government, courts, and peace among nations. The presence of these prayers shows that the Church does not exclude civic concerns from its spiritual life. Rather, it places those concerns within a theological framework of justice, peace, humility, and accountability before God.

The distinction is subtle but essential. The Church may pray for the nation without making the nation the subject of its worship.

5. A Musicological Question: When Does a Patriotic Song Become a Hymn?

The theological question of patriotic music is inseparable from a musicological one: what distinguishes a hymn from a national song, a ceremonial anthem, or another form of communal singing? The answer cannot be determined by musical style alone.

Christian hymnody has borrowed melodies and musical forms from numerous cultural traditions. Folk songs, chorales, metrical psalm tunes, spirituals, and contemporary popular idioms have all contributed to the Church’s musical vocabulary. A melody’s secular origin does not automatically disqualify it from sacred use. Conversely, a melody’s inclusion in a hymnal does not automatically make every text associated with it an appropriate expression of Christian faith.

Text, function, and context

A useful starting point is the distinction between a hymn’s musical form and its liturgical function.

A hymn is not merely a strophic song with religious references. Within Christian worship, hymnody serves as a means of proclamation, prayer, praise, confession, thanksgiving, and spiritual formation. Its theological function depends upon what the congregation is being asked to sing and why.

Consider the following questions: Who or what is the subject of the text? To whom is the song addressed? What convictions does the text invite the congregation to affirm? How does the song function within the surrounding liturgy?

These questions carry considerable weight when we recognize that congregational singing is more than the performance of music. A congregation does not merely observe a text being performed. When it sings, it gives collective voice to the text’s assertions, petitions, and convictions. This is one reason hymn selection requires theological scrutiny.

The congregation’s participation may communicate assent to a text’s implications, even when those implications have not been consciously considered by every singer.

The formative power of congregational song

The ancient principle lex orandi, lex credendi, commonly summarized as the relationship between the law of prayer and the law of belief, is particularly relevant.

The phrase expresses the conviction that worship and belief are intimately connected. Christian worship does not simply reflect what the Church believes; it also contributes to the formation of those beliefs.

In this sense, congregational singing is an act of theological education. Repeatedly singing that Christ reigns over all creation reinforces the Church’s understanding of divine sovereignty. Repeatedly singing about forgiveness, reconciliation, and love of enemies shapes the congregation’s moral imagination. By the same reasoning, repeatedly incorporating national songs into Christian worship may teach the congregation to associate patriotic feeling with religious devotion.

Even when worship planners intend only to acknowledge a civic holiday, the musical act itself may communicate a more complicated message. A patriotic song sung in a civic auditorium is heard within one interpretive framework. The same song sung during the Sunday Eucharist, surrounded by prayers, Scripture, and sacramental action, acquires a different significance.

The liturgical setting can lend sacred authority to a text whose primary purpose is national affirmation. This is not necessarily the intention of the worship planners, but it may be the effect.

The power of musical association

Music possesses a distinctive capacity to evoke collective memory.

National anthems are particularly effective in this respect. Their melodies become associated with ceremonies, public rituals, athletic events, military observances, and shared experiences of national identity. The opening measures of “The Star-Spangled Banner,” for example, immediately summon a recognizable set of civic associations for many Americans.

These associations do not disappear when the anthem is performed in a church. Indeed, the ceremonial atmosphere of Christian worship may intensify them.

A congregation standing to sing the national anthem within the sanctuary may experience an emotional continuity between reverence for God and reverence for the nation, even though the two acts are theologically distinct. This phenomenon illustrates why musical meaning cannot be reduced to the literal content of a text. Melody, ritual posture, performance tradition, memory, and physical setting all contribute to the meaning of a musical act. A worship planner who evaluates patriotic music solely by asking whether its words contain anything explicitly contrary to Scripture overlooks much of what music communicates.

The distinction between performance and congregational participation

It may be tempting to argue that a patriotic selection becomes less problematic when performed instrumentally or by a choir rather than sung by the congregation. There is some merit to this distinction. Congregational singing constitutes a particularly direct form of communal affirmation. An instrumental prelude does not require worshipers to articulate a text, while a choral anthem permits a degree of reflective distance between listeners and performers.

Nevertheless, neither distinction eliminates the importance of context. An instrumental arrangement of “God Bless America” still carries the cultural associations of the original song. A choral performance of a national anthem still introduces national symbolism into the liturgical environment. The question therefore extends beyond the presence or absence of sung words.

Music communicates through association as well as text, and liturgical placement is itself an act of interpretation.

A patriotic instrumental selection used as background music during a community reception may be entirely appropriate. The same arrangement used as the prelude to Holy Communion may communicate a theological association that was neither intended nor carefully examined. This is why the distinction between sacred and secular music cannot be resolved through a simplistic classification of musical genres. The more useful distinction concerns the relationship between the music’s meaning and the purpose of the gathering.

6. “God Bless America”: A Theological Examination

Few songs illustrate the tensions between American patriotism and Christian worship more clearly than Irving Berlin’s “God Bless America.”

Originally written in 1918 and revised for public performance in 1938, the song became one of the most recognizable expressions of American patriotic sentiment. Its cultural importance is considerable. It has been performed in times of national celebration, public mourning, war, and collective uncertainty. Yet cultural importance and liturgical appropriateness are different questions.

Is it wrong to ask God to bless America?

Not necessarily.

Scripture provides ample precedent for praying for the welfare of a particular community. As previously noted, Jeremiah 29:7 instructs the people of Judah to seek the welfare of Babylon, while First Timothy 2:1–2 encourages prayer for rulers and political authorities.

The theological problem is not the act of asking God to bless one’s country. It is the meaning attached to that request.

If “God bless America” means “May God grant the people of this nation peace, justice, wisdom, compassion, and freedom from oppression,” the petition is entirely compatible with Christian prayer.

If, however, the phrase implies that America occupies a uniquely favored position before God, or that its national interests deserve divine support over those of other nations, the theological implications become considerably more troubling.

The distinction lies between intercession and exceptionalism. Christian prayer may seek God’s blessing for a nation, but it must remain consistent with the conviction that God’s love is not limited by national boundaries.

The command to love one’s neighbor

In Matthew 22:37–40, Jesus identifies love of God and love of neighbor as the two greatest commandments. The command to love one’s neighbor is not restricted to those who share one’s citizenship.

Indeed, in Luke 10:25–37, Jesus uses the parable of the Good Samaritan to challenge assumptions about the boundaries of neighborly obligation.

The Samaritan is not the expected religious or social insider. He becomes the example of neighborly love precisely because he crosses a boundary that others have failed to cross. This understanding of neighborly love should also shape the way Christians pray, extending our concern beyond the boundaries of nationality and citizenship. A prayer that seeks the welfare of Americans while remaining indifferent to the suffering of people elsewhere would be inconsistent with the expansive understanding of neighborly love taught by Jesus.

Matthew 5:44 goes further:

“But I say to you: Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you.” (NRSVue)

This command is especially challenging in the context of international conflict. Christians are not merely permitted to pray for those regarded as national enemies. They are commanded to love and pray for their enemies.

A Christian congregation therefore cannot allow its national identity to determine the boundaries of its compassion. It may pray for American soldiers and their families, but it must also be capable of praying for civilians, soldiers, and families on the opposing side of a conflict. It may lament American casualties, but it must also recognize the suffering of those whose deaths may never be commemorated by American civic institutions.

The gospel does not require the abandonment of national affection. It does require that such affection be subordinate to a love that extends beyond the nation.

The problem of implied divine favoritism

A particularly troubling feature of nationalistic religious expression is the suggestion that God endorses the political destiny of a particular nation. The Hebrew Scriptures repeatedly challenge such assumptions.

In Amos 9:7, God reminds Israel that divine activity is not limited to Israel’s own national history. The passage references God’s involvement with other peoples, thereby challenging the notion that Israel’s relationship with God guarantees unquestioned national privilege.

The prophetic tradition also insists that covenant identity does not exempt a nation from judgment. Indeed, Israel’s special relationship with God intensifies its responsibility to practice justice and righteousness. This is an important corrective to any modern attempt to identify a nation with God’s purposes.

Even biblical Israel, whose covenantal identity occupies a unique place within Scripture, was not granted immunity from divine criticism. How much less justification is there for assuming that the United States, or any modern nation-state, possesses an exclusive claim upon divine favor?

Christian theology does not provide a warrant for treating the United States as a new covenant nation or the privileged instrument of God’s redemptive work. The Church, not the nation-state, is the community gathered through the saving work of Jesus Christ, and even the Church exists under God’s judgment and mercy rather than above them.

The strongest defense of patriotic prayer

A fair examination must acknowledge that not all patriotic religious language expresses national superiority.

For many Christians, “God Bless America” is simply a familiar petition for the welfare of their country. Its performance may express gratitude, grief, hope, or solidarity rather than a belief in American exceptionalism.

Similarly, “America the Beautiful” contains language that explicitly acknowledges the nation’s imperfections and asks for moral correction. Such language deserves consideration when evaluating patriotic songs within a Christian context, and it would be unfair to assume that every congregation singing one intends to elevate the nation above God. Nevertheless, the sincerity of the participants does not, in itself, settle the question of liturgical appropriateness.

A song may be emotionally meaningful, historically important, and morally well-intentioned while still being poorly suited to the central acts of Christian worhsip.

The decisive question is not whether patriotic sentiment can be expressed faithfully by Christians. It is whether that sentiment should become a defining feature of the Church’s assembled worship.

The Church possesses an extensive vocabulary of intercession through which it can pray for the nation without adopting the ceremonial language of national celebration. That vocabulary is both more theologically precise and more consistent with the universal character of Christian worship.

7. Christian Nationalism and the Historical Dangers of Sacred Patriotism

The relationship between Christianity and nationalism is not merely a theoretical concern. History provides numerous examples of the consequences that arise when religious institutions become closely identified with political authority. It is important, however, to distinguish between patriotism, nationalism, and Christian nationalism.

Patriotism generally refers to affection for one’s country, its people, history, and institutions. Such affection may inspire public service, civic responsibility, and concern for the common good.

Nationalism places greater emphasis on the nation as a defining political and cultural identity. Its expressions vary considerably, ranging from movements for national self-determination to exclusionary ideologies that elevate one national community over others.

Christian nationalism, in the American context, generally describes an ideological framework in which American national identity is closely associated with Christianity and in which political institutions are expected to preserve or promote that association.

These categories should not be carelessly conflated. A Christian may love the United States, participate in elections, serve in the military, and advocate for public policies informed by religious convictions without embracing Christian nationalism. The danger emerges when national identity acquires theological authority or when Christianity becomes an instrument for legitimizing the nation.

Lessons from the twentieth century

The history of European Christianity in the twentieth century offers a sobering illustration of this danger.

In Nazi Germany, the Deutsche Christen (German Christians) movement sought to align Protestant Christianity with National Socialist ideology. Its proponents attempted to reshape the Church according to racial and national categories, subordinating Christian theology to the political and cultural priorities of the Nazi regime. Central to this effort was the establishment of a Reichskirche (Reich Church), a unified national Protestant church that would consolidate Germany’s regional Protestant churches under centralized leadership sympathetic to Hitler and the Nazi state. Rather than preserving the Church’s independence as a theological and spiritual institution, the movement envisioned a church whose identity, governance, and teachings would reflect the racial nationalism of the Third Reich. This included efforts to remove Jewish influences from Christian theology, reinterpret Scripture through the lens of Nazi ideology, and promote an understanding of Christianity inseparable from German national identity. The creation of the German Evangelical Church in 1933 represented a major step toward this goal, although efforts to bring German Protestantism fully under Nazi control encountered substantial resistance, most notably from the emerging Confessing Church. The episode offers a sobering historical example of what can happen when the Church allows national identity and political ideology to determine the boundaries of Christian faith and practice.

The Theological Declaration of Barmen (1934), associated especially with Karl Barth and other leaders of the Confessing Church, rejected the notion that the Church could recognize political ideologies or historical powers as sources of revelation alongside Jesus Christ. Its central theological claim was that the Church belongs to Christ and must not surrender its proclamation to competing authorities.

The circumstances of Nazi Germany are historically specific and should not be equated casually with contemporary American church practices.

Singing “America the Beautiful” on a Sunday morning is not equivalent to supporting an authoritarian political movement.

Nevertheless, the historical example illustrates a principle of enduring importance: when the Church permits national identity to shape its theology and worship without critical examination, it risks compromising its independence and prophetic responsibility.

American civil religion

Robert Bellah’s analysis of American civil religion provides a more immediate framework. American civil religion includes references to God, providence, sacrifice, national destiny, and moral obligation within public life. These expressions may unite citizens across denominational and religious differences. They may also provide a language through which the nation reflects upon its responsibilities and failures.

Yet civil religion is not identical to Christianity.

The God invoked in a presidential address or patriotic anthem may function primarily as the guarantor of national ideals rather than as the God revealed in the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus Christ.

The distinction is not always obvious because the language may be similar. Words such as blessing, sacrifice, freedom, redemption, and providence appear in both Christian theology and American patriotic rhetoric, but their meanings are not necessarily the same.

For Christians, redemption is grounded in Christ. Freedom is not merely political independence but liberation from sin and death. Sacrifice is interpreted through the cross, which challenges conventional understandings of power and victory.

When national narratives appropriate these theological categories, they may acquire a sacred significance that Christian theology cannot uncritically endorse.

The United Methodist witness

This concern is not foreign to contemporary United Methodist teaching. The denomination’s 2020/2024 Book of Resolutions includes Resolution 5306, “Social Principles as a Guide to Combating Extreme Nationalism.”

The resolution warns against forms of nationalism that advance the interests of one nation to the exclusion or detriment of others. It also calls the Church to evaluate political and cultural allegiances through Scripture and the Social Principles.

The United Methodist Social Principles further affirm that Christian political engagement must be rooted in love of neighbor, justice, human dignity, and concern for the vulnerable.

These teachings do not demand political withdrawal. On the contrary, they encourage Christians to participate responsibly in public life. They do, however, establish a theological basis for distinguishing Christian discipleship from unquestioning national loyalty. This distinction should be reflected in worship.

A congregation that sings about justice, peace, and reconciliation on Sunday should be prepared to question national policies and practices that contradict those values. The Church’s prophetic independence is diminished when its worship becomes a celebration of the very political institutions it may be called to challenge.

8. A Wesleyan Perspective: Holiness, Justice, and the Universal Love of God

For United Methodists, the question of patriotic worship can also be examined through the theological inheritance of John and Charles Wesley. Wesleyan theology emphasizes the inseparable relationship between love of God and love of neighbor. John Wesley’s understanding of holiness was not confined to private religious devotion. Christian perfection, as he understood it, involved the transformation of the believer through love, expressed in relationships with God and others. The Wesleyan tradition therefore offers no justification for a Christianity that celebrates national identity while neglecting the suffering of people beyond national borders.

Social holiness and Christian responsibility

Wesley’s understanding of social holiness emphasizes that Christian faith is not merely a matter of personal belief or individual piety, but is lived in community and expressed through concrete acts of mercy and justice. The contemporary United Methodist Church continues this theological inheritance through its Social Principles, which connect personal discipleship with public responsibility.

Such a perspective provides a framework for praying for the nation without celebrating it uncritically. The Church may give thanks for political freedoms while recognizing that those freedoms have not always been extended equally. It may honor those who have served in the military while lamenting the suffering caused by war. It may pray for elected officials while retaining the freedom to challenge their actions. It may express gratitude for its homeland while acknowledging the dignity and legitimate aspirations of other nations.

In each instance, the Church’s primary responsibility is not to defend national prestige but to bear witness to God’s justice and mercy.

Charles Wesley and the theological function of hymnody

The Wesleyan understanding of hymnody provides another important consideration. Charles Wesley’s hymns were not merely devotional embellishments. They were instruments of theological instruction. Through congregational singing, Methodists learned about grace, repentance, sanctification, the incarnation, the cross, and the resurrection. Hymnody functioned as sung theology. This historical understanding places considerable responsibility upon those who select music for worship.

If congregational singing contributes to theological formation, the Church must ask whether its selected texts teach the convictions it wishes to cultivate.

Does a patriotic song teach the congregation about the universal love of God? Does it deepen its understanding of Christian discipleship? Does it express the Church’s identity as the body of Christ?

Or does it primarily reinforce national belonging?

The distinction matters because the Church’s musical resources are not neutral. Every congregational hymn participates, in some measure, in the theological formation of the people who sing it.

9. Not All National Hymns Are Theologically Equivalent

A responsible approach to this subject must avoid treating every hymn associated with national life as though it communicates the same theological message. The United Methodist Hymnal itself provides examples of significantly different approaches to nationhood, peace, and Christian responsibility.

“America the Beautiful” (UMH 696)
A patriotic text containing petitions for moral reform and national responsibility. Its acknowledgment of national shortcomings is theologically valuable, but the nation remains the central subject.

“This Is My Song” (UMH 437)
Lloyd Stone’s text, associated with Sibelius’s FINLANDIA, acknowledges affection for one’s homeland while recognizing that people in other countries possess the same affection and aspirations. It offers a particularly useful alternative to national exceptionalism.

“O God of Every Nation” (UMH 435)
William W. Reid Jr.’s hymn addresses God as sovereign over all peoples and prays for peace, justice, and reconciliation. Its theological subject is universal rather than nationally particular.

These examples illustrate why theological discernment must operate at the level of individual texts rather than broad categories. A hymn that mentions a nation is not necessarily nationalistic. Likewise, a hymn that contains references to God is not necessarily appropriate for Christian worship.

“This Is My Song” as a theological alternative

“This Is My Song” is especially valuable because it recognizes a legitimate human affection for one’s homeland while resisting the temptation to make that affection exclusive. The text acknowledges that people elsewhere cherish their own countries, landscapes, histories, and communities. Its perspective is therefore both particular and universal. It does not require Christians to deny their national identities. Instead, it places those identities within a broader recognition of shared humanity. This approach is more consistent with the biblical command to love one’s neighbor and with the Church’s identity as a community drawn from every nation.

The musical setting also contributes to the hymn’s effectiveness. Sibelius’s FINLANDIA possesses strong national associations of its own, having emerged from the composer’s Finnish patriotic work. Yet its use with Stone’s text transforms the musical material into a vehicle for international solidarity. The example demonstrates how a melody with nationalist historical associations can be reinterpreted through a text that challenges narrow nationalism. The theological meaning emerges from the relationship between text, music, and liturgical context.

“O God of Every Nation”

“O God of Every Nation” offers an even more explicitly theological alternative. Rather than celebrating the accomplishments or aspirations of a particular country, it addresses God as the sovereign of all nations. Its petitions concern justice, peace, and the healing of divisions among peoples. The text therefore avoids the ambiguity that accompanies many patriotic songs. It does not ask the congregation to affirm a particular national narrative. It asks the congregation to pray for a world transformed by God’s justice and love.

Such a hymn may be especially appropriate when the appointed Scriptures address conflict, reconciliation, the responsibilities of rulers, or the universal reign of Christ. Its appropriateness derives not from the fact that it appears in the hymnal, but from its theological content and relationship to the liturgy.

10. A Practical Framework for Liturgical Discernment

If the presence of a song in the hymnal is insufficient to establish its appropriateness for worship, how should clergy and church musicians make these decisions? A useful framework begins with the purpose of the service rather than the availability or popularity of particular music. The following questions may guide the process.

QuestionLiturgical consideration
Who is the subject?Does the song primarily proclaim God’s character and work, or celebrate the nation?
What does the text teach?Are its theological assertions consistent with Scripture and the Church’s teaching?
What is its function?Does it serve praise, prayer, proclamation, confession, thanksgiving, or another identifiable liturgical purpose?
Why this Sunday?Is the selection related to the appointed Scriptures and Christian calendar, or principally to a civic holiday?
What does the music communicate?Do its historical and cultural associations reinforce or complicate the intended theological message?
Whom does it include?Can the assembled Church participate without being asked to affirm a particular national or political identity?
What precedent does it establish?Does its inclusion strengthen the distinction between Christian and civic identity, or weaken it?

No single question resolves every situation. Taken together, however, they encourage a more thoughtful approach to worship planning.

The distinction between a service of worship and a civic gathering

A particularly useful principle is that different gatherings may legitimately have different purposes. A community Veterans Day ceremony may appropriately include the national anthem, recognition of military service, patriotic music, and civic addresses. A church-sponsored Independence Day concert may include American folk songs, patriotic hymns, and instrumental music associated with national history. A Christian funeral for a veteran may incorporate military honors as a distinct component of the broader occasion, subject to the Church’s pastoral and liturgical guidelines.

None of these examples requires the Church to transform its ordinary Sunday worship into a patriotic celebration.

The distinction is not between sacred and secular activities in a way that devalues the latter. Rather, it recognizes that different gatherings serve different purposes. A civic ceremony should be permitted to function as a civic ceremony. Christian worship should be permitted to remain Christian worship.

The particular question of Veterans Day

Veterans Day offers a practical example. A congregation may wish to acknowledge veterans among its membership. The impulse is understandable and often arises from genuine affection and gratitude. Yet several distinctions should guide the response.

First, Veterans Day honors military service, while Memorial Day commemorates those who died in military service. Neither is inherently a Christian feast.

Second, military service is not a sacrament, an ecclesiastical office, or a distinct category of Christian holiness.

Third, the Church’s responsibility toward veterans extends beyond public recognition. It includes pastoral care, support for families, attention to the consequences of war, and concern for those experiencing physical or psychological suffering.

A congregation might therefore choose to recognize Veterans Day through a fellowship gathering, a community meal, a special program, or a pastoral ministry initiative.

Within Sunday worship, the congregation might offer prayers for veterans, active-duty personnel, military families, civilian victims of war, and all who labor for peace.

Such prayers can be appropriate when they remain intercessory rather than celebratory and when they are integrated into the broader prayers of the Church.

A prayer for those affected by military service is not the same as a ceremonial tribute to the military.

This distinction allows the Church to respond pastorally to the realities of its community without confusing its liturgical identity with that of the nation.

11. A Necessary Qualification: Civic Concerns Can Belong in Christian Worship

An argument against patriotic celebrations within worship must not become an argument for ignoring public life altogether. Christian worship is not an escape from political or social responsibility. Scripture repeatedly addresses justice, poverty, oppression, war, peace, and the responsibilities of rulers. The prophets condemn political corruption and the mistreatment of vulnerable people. Jesus announces good news to the poor and challenges structures of exclusion. The New Testament calls Christians to pray for those in authority and to pursue peace.

Consequently, Christian worship may appropriately address national events, public tragedies, political injustice, and the moral responsibilities of citizenship. The distinction lies in how those concerns are addressed. A sermon confronting racial injustice is not equivalent to a patriotic speech celebrating national identity. A prayer for peace during an international conflict is not equivalent to a ceremony endorsing a nation’s military objectives. A lament for victims of political violence is not equivalent to a partisan rally.

Christian worship may engage political realities precisely because the gospel has implications for public life. The Church’s responsibility is to interpret those realities through Scripture and Christian theology rather than allowing national or partisan narratives to determine the content of worship.

The Episcopal and United Methodist traditions already provide a model

Both traditions possess liturgical resources for addressing national concerns without making patriotism the organizing principle of worship. The Episcopal Book of Common Prayer includes intercessions for the nation, those in authority, the welfare of the world, and peace among nations. Its prayer “For the Nation” asks for justice, restraint, and the faithful use of liberty. The United Methodist Book of Worship likewise includes prayers addressing national life and international responsibility. One prayer, attributed to the Church of Pakistan, asks God to correct the nation where it is in error and to sustain it where it acts with justice and compassion. Another prayer asks Christians to examine national policies through the perspective of faith and to resist the prejudices that contribute to conflict. These resources were highlighted by the Iowa Annual Conference in its 2026 materials addressing the United States’ 250th anniversary.

Such prayers offer a striking contrast to triumphalist patriotic expression. They do not presume that the nation is righteous. They place the nation under God’s judgment and mercy. The Church is not called to affirm a nation’s virtue or righteousness, but to proclaim the Gospel’s call to justice, repentance, and reconciliation, a call that extends to all people, including the Church itself.

12. Responding to the Argument: “But It’s in the Hymnal”

The central argument can now be stated with greater precision.

When someone asks whether a song is appropriate for worship because it appears in the denominational hymnal, several responses are necessary.

First, the hymnal is a collection of resources for many occasions, not a prescribed order of worship.

Second, the inclusion of a song reflects an editorial judgment made within a particular historical and denominational context. That judgment deserves respect but is not beyond theological examination.

Third, the appropriateness of a song depends upon its text, musical associations, liturgical function, and relationship to the theological purpose of the gathering.

Fourth, the presence of patriotic songs in a hymnal does not erase the distinction between Christian worship and civic observance.

Finally, the publication of a hymnal does not relieve the Church of its ongoing responsibility to exercise theological discernment in the selection and use of music for worship.

The Church continues to interpret Scripture, examine its traditions, reconsider its language, and respond to new historical circumstances. A hymn that was considered appropriate in 1989 may warrant renewed examination in 2026. The same is true of hymns published in 1889, 1789, or any other period. Age does not guarantee theological soundness, and recent publication does not guarantee theological relevance. The test is not simply whether a text has survived, but whether it faithfully serves the Church’s proclamation today.

An argument from consistency

There is also a straightforward logical problem with the claim that inclusion establishes appropriateness. If every item in a hymnal were equally appropriate for ordinary Sunday worship, there would be little reason for the hymnal to distinguish between morning hymns, evening hymns, seasonal hymns, canticles, service music, and songs for particular occasions. Yet such distinctions exist precisely because context matters.

A Magnificat setting may be especially appropriate for Evening Prayer. A hymn about the resurrection may be especially appropriate for Easter. A national anthem may be appropriate for a civic observance.

None of these conclusions follows merely from the presence of the music in a denominational collection. Rather, each depends upon the relationship between the selection and the occasion. The hymnal itself, through its organization and variety, implicitly acknowledges this principle. Therefore, the argument that a patriotic song is appropriate for Sunday worship simply because it appears in the hymnal is not only theologically insufficient, it is inconsistent with the way hymnals are designed to function.

Conclusion: Whose Kingdom Do We Proclaim?

The question of patriotic music in Christian worship ultimately concerns the identity of the Church. Christians may love their country, honor those who serve their communities, participate in civic life, and pray earnestly for the welfare of their nation. None of these activities is inherently inconsistent with Christian faith. Yet Christian worship makes a claim that transcends national belonging.

When the Church gathers, it does not assemble primarily as Americans, Canadians, or citizens of any other nation. It gathers as the body of Christ. Its prayers are offered to the God of all creation. Its Scriptures proclaim a kingdom that transcends political boundaries. Its sacraments unite people whose national, cultural, and historical identities may be profoundly different.

Its music should bear witness to that same reality. The presence of national songs in denominational hymnals is an important part of the historical record of American Christianity. Such songs may possess considerable cultural, musical, and emotional value, but historical preservation is not the same as liturgical endorsement.

A hymnal provides the Church with resources. It does not relieve clergy and musicians of their responsibility to evaluate those resources through Scripture, theology, and the purposes of Christian worship. The Church must therefore be willing to distinguish between what is familiar and what is faithful, between what is culturally meaningful and what is liturgically appropriate.

This distinction does not diminish the nation. It places the nation within its proper theological context. To pray for one’s country is an act of Christian responsibility. To love one’s neighbors, including those beyond national borders, is a commandment of Christ. To proclaim the reign of God over every earthly authority is an essential expression of Christian faith.

The Church can honor all three commitments without allowing patriotic celebration to become the organizing principle of its worship.

Preserving this distinction may be one of the most important ways the Church demonstrates its love for the nation: by refusing to grant it the unquestioned authority that belongs to God alone.

The question is not whether Christians may love their country. The question is whether the Church’s worship makes unmistakably clear that its highest allegiance belongs to Jesus Christ.


Recommended Reading


Editorial note: This article argues for a disciplined distinction between civic observance and the Church’s ordinary Sunday liturgy. It does not claim that either the United Methodist or Episcopal Church categorically prohibits national songs in worship. Both traditions provide authorized resources for national occasions. The argument is that permission, historical inclusion, and theological suitability are separate questions, and that Christian worship requires discernment beyond the contents of the hymnal.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Nobody Tailgates for Brahms

June 15, 2026 by Clay

There’s a reason ESPN broadcasts football games and not freshman juries.

For more than a century, colleges and universities in the United States have fought an ongoing cultural tug-of-war between athletics and the arts. Faculty meetings, budget committees, alumni boards, and state legislatures have all asked the same question in different forms: what deserves institutional investment? The arts departments point to cultural enrichment, intellectual development, creativity, and the preservation of human expression. Athletic departments point to enrollment, visibility, alumni engagement, television contracts, ticket sales, and money. Mountains of money.

As someone who makes a living in music, I’ll offer a hot take that many of my colleagues in the arts world probably won’t appreciate: when you can fill a 50,000-seat arena for a choral concert, then we can talk.

That statement sounds harsh at first, especially coming from a musician. But it reflects a reality that colleges and universities have understood for decades. Athletics, particularly football and basketball, function as revenue engines in American higher education in a way that most arts programs simply do not. Major athletic programs bring in television deals worth millions, attract donors, sell merchandise, drive alumni engagement, and create a public identity for institutions that would otherwise remain regionally unknown.

A winning football program can increase applications to a university almost overnight. A deep run in the NCAA basketball tournament can generate national exposure equivalent to millions of dollars in advertising. Stadiums seat tens of thousands of people because demand exists for tens of thousands of people to attend. The emotional connection Americans have with collegiate athletics is tribal, generational, and deeply woven into regional identity. In many parts of the country, the university football team is the closest thing the community has to a professional franchise.

Music programs operate in a completely different ecosystem.

Even the most elite collegiate music schools rarely draw audiences remotely comparable to athletic events. A university orchestra might perform brilliantly to an audience of 400 people. A choir might spend months preparing a masterwork only to sing for a half-filled concert hall. Faculty and students often look at the sprawling football facilities across campus and wonder why their practice rooms still contain broken pianos and chairs from the Reagan administration.

Their frustration is understandable.

But arts advocates sometimes make the mistake of pretending the comparison is economically equivalent. It isn’t. Football programs at major universities can bring in tens or even hundreds of millions of dollars annually. March Madness television revenue alone has become a financial juggernaut. Most collegiate arts programs, meanwhile, operate almost entirely as educational and cultural missions rather than revenue-producing enterprises.

That does not make them less important.

In fact, one of the great failures of modern American education is the tendency to measure everything by immediate profitability. Music education matters because human beings need beauty, expression, storytelling, collaboration, and emotional depth. A society that funds only what turns a profit eventually becomes spiritually hollow. Universities are not supposed to function exclusively as corporations. They are meant to cultivate human beings.

Music programs teach discipline every bit as rigorous as athletics. Musicians practice for thousands of hours in isolation. They learn collaboration, leadership, time management, listening skills, and emotional intelligence. Ensemble performance requires extraordinary teamwork. A choir functions with many of the same interpersonal dynamics as a sports team: accountability, preparation, sacrifice, and collective trust.

The difference is that society celebrates one kind of teamwork more visibly than the other.

Part of this discrepancy comes down to audience accessibility. Sports are immediate. You do not need formal training to understand whether a touchdown was exciting. Athletics create instant drama with clear winners and losers. The emotional payoff is obvious. Classical music, on the other hand, often requires cultural familiarity that many audiences simply do not possess. Someone attending a Mahler symphony for the first time may not have the contextual framework to appreciate it fully. Sports ask very little of audiences initially. Classical music often asks for patience, concentration, and education.

That gap matters.

In many ways, arts organizations and university music departments have struggled for decades with accessibility and public engagement. While athletics aggressively market themselves as entertainment experiences, classical music institutions often market themselves with a tone of reverence that unintentionally alienates newcomers. Football games are loud, communal, emotional, and intentionally inclusive. Symphony concerts can sometimes feel formal, rigid, and intimidating to audiences unfamiliar with concert etiquette.

Meanwhile, athletic programs have mastered spectacle.

College football is not merely a sporting event. It is an all-day cultural ritual. Tailgates, fight songs, mascots, traditions, uniforms, lights, student sections, alumni gatherings, and marching bands all combine into something closer to theater than pure competition. Ironically, some of the most visible arts education in America happens directly inside athletic culture.

The marching band may be the single greatest example of athletics and arts coexisting successfully on a college campus.

Every Saturday in the fall, tens of thousands of people cheer for musicians. They may think they came for football, but halftime often becomes one of the most memorable parts of the experience. Marching bands provide pageantry, emotional identity, school tradition, and communal energy. Fight songs become sonic symbols of institutional pride. In many cases, the band is the heartbeat of the stadium.

And here’s the irony: athletic departments often provide arts programs with their largest audiences.

A university choir concert may attract 200 attendees. A marching band performs for 50,000. One ensemble is considered financially expendable while the other becomes institutionally indispensable because it contributes directly to the athletic product. The relationship between athletics and music is therefore not purely competitive. It is symbiotic.

The smartest universities understand this.

Rather than framing athletics and arts programs as enemies competing for scraps, successful institutions recognize that both contribute to campus identity in different ways. Athletics create visibility and revenue. Arts programs create culture and humanity. One brings people to campus. The other helps give the campus a soul.

The problem arises when one side begins dismissing the value of the other.

Arts faculty sometimes speak about athletics as though sports are intellectually beneath them. Athletic supporters sometimes dismiss the arts as financially useless luxuries. Both perspectives are shortsighted. A university without athletics may struggle for visibility, alumni engagement, and financial growth. A university without the arts becomes sterile, transactional, and emotionally empty.

Students deserve both.

A campus should have roaring stadiums and beautiful concert halls. It should produce quarterbacks and composers, conductors and point guards, trumpet players and linebackers. Human civilization has always needed competition and creativity. Ancient societies held athletic contests and artistic festivals side by side because both fulfilled essential parts of communal life.

Still, economic realities cannot simply be ignored.

If a university president must decide between cutting a program that loses millions and protecting one that generates millions, the decision is often predictable. That does not necessarily mean the decision is morally correct, but it does mean it is institutionally rational. Universities today face immense financial pressures, declining enrollment in some regions, rising operational costs, and public scrutiny over tuition. In that environment, revenue-producing programs naturally receive protection.

This is where arts advocates must become more strategic.

Rather than pretending music programs can compete with athletics on pure revenue, arts departments should emphasize the broader value they provide: recruitment, retention, interdisciplinary education, community engagement, donor relations, public outreach, and institutional prestige. They should also rethink how performances are presented and marketed. Audiences crave connection and experience. The arts world sometimes forgets that excellence alone does not guarantee attendance.

The goal should not be to turn orchestras into football games.

The goal should be to remember that audiences are human beings looking for meaning, excitement, belonging, and emotional connection. Athletics succeed because they create communal experiences people want to share. The arts can do the same when they stop assuming audiences will automatically come simply because the performance is culturally important.

At their best, athletics and the arts actually pursue similar ideals. Both celebrate human potential. Both demand discipline. Both create identity and community. Both can inspire transcendence. A stadium roaring after a last-second touchdown and a concert hall sitting in stunned silence after a perfect cadence are not as different as they appear.

Both are moments where human beings gather to feel something larger than themselves.

So yes, my hot take still stands: when you can fill a 50,000-seat arena for a choral concert, then we can talk.

But maybe the deeper truth is this: universities need the people who fill the stadium, and they also need the people who write the fight song.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

AI Can Write Songs. It Can’t Sweat Under Stage Lights.

May 16, 2026 by Clay

Artificial intelligence has now crossed a threshold that many musicians hoped would remain hypothetical for a little while longer. AI-generated artists are appearing on Billboard charts, earning streams, signing deals, and in some cases fooling listeners entirely. Projects like Xania Monet and Breaking Rust have already charted on Billboard and streaming platforms, signaling that AI music is no longer a novelty confined to internet experiments.

As someone whose life has been shaped by rehearsals, choirs, worship services, theater pits, classrooms, and live stages, I do not support the use of AI to create music. I understand the appeal of efficiency. I understand the fascination with technology. But music is one of the few remaining art forms that depends not only on sound, but on humanity itself. Music is memory, breath, imperfection, risk, and lived experience. A machine can imitate style, but it cannot suffer, rejoice, mourn, love, believe, or wrestle with meaning.

What troubles me most is not necessarily the technology itself, but the growing willingness to replace artistic labor with algorithmic convenience. AI-generated music is often defended as “just another tool,” but there is a meaningful difference between using technology to assist creativity and allowing technology to become the creator. A microphone amplifies a singer. Recording software edits a performance. A synthesizer expands a palette of sounds. Those technologies still depend on a human being making artistic decisions. Generative AI, however, attempts to bypass the deeply human process altogether.

At the same time, I cannot deny reality. AI music is here, and it will likely continue growing. Billboard itself has documented the increasing presence of AI-generated artists on the charts, and major conversations are now happening throughout the music industry about what authenticity even means in the streaming era. We are entering a moment where listeners may genuinely struggle to distinguish between human-created and machine-generated recordings.

Ironically, I believe this development may strengthen live music rather than destroy it.

For decades, recorded music has steadily become more polished, corrected, compressed, edited, and detached from the physical reality of performance. Entire generations have grown accustomed to hearing music that could never actually happen on a stage. AI may push that trend so far that audiences begin craving the exact opposite: authenticity. They will want to know a human being is truly singing. They will want to hear breaths between phrases, imperfections in pitch, spontaneous interaction, unrehearsed moments, and the energy that exists only in a room full of living people.

I see this every week in my work at the Gaslight Theatre. In many ways, the Gaslight Theatre understands something Silicon Valley never will: audiences are not looking for perfection nearly as much as they are looking for humanity. The entire experience of melodrama theater depends on human unpredictability. Audiences are not simply attending to hear songs or watch a polished production. They come for the improvisation, the occasional mistakes, the cast interactions, the ad-libs, the audience participation, and the feeling that anything could happen at any moment. Some of the loudest laughter and strongest audience reactions come from moments no AI could ever predict or replicate. The imperfections are not flaws in the performance; they are often the very thing that makes the performance memorable.

In many ways, the enduring success of the Gaslight model reveals something important about audiences today. Even in an age dominated by streaming algorithms and digital entertainment, people still pack theaters to watch live human beings create something together in real time. They want spontaneity. They want risk. They want to feel connected to performers who are visibly and emotionally present in the room with them. That desire for authenticity may become even stronger as AI-generated entertainment becomes more common.

A live concert offers something AI can never fully replicate: presence. No algorithm can recreate the communal experience of hundreds of people singing together at a concert, the tension before a downbeat, or the electricity of a performer responding to the audience in real time. Music has always been deeply social. Even in an increasingly digital culture, people still crave gathering around shared human experiences. In fact, the more artificial media becomes, the more valuable authentic presence will become.

That means artists should stop thinking of live performance as secondary to streaming success. In the coming years, live performance may become the primary marker of legitimacy. Artists who build genuine communities around concerts, local performances, touring ensembles, and interactive experiences will likely have a stronger long-term future than artists chasing algorithmic virality alone.

Musicians can prepare for this shift in practical ways. First, artists need to become exceptional live performers. Audiences are no longer paying simply to hear songs; they are paying to experience personality, storytelling, connection, and artistry in real time. Strong stage presence, audience engagement, thoughtful programming, and emotional honesty matter more than ever.

Second, artists should lean into locality and community. AI-generated music thrives in anonymous digital spaces, but human music thrives in relationships. Local concert series, house concerts, collaborations with community organizations, church music programs, regional theater, chamber ensembles, and independent venues all create spaces where audiences encounter real people instead of content streams. Musicians who cultivate those relationships will remain valuable regardless of technological trends.

Third, artists should document the human process behind their work. Audiences increasingly want to see rehearsal footage, songwriting sessions, recording outtakes, conversations with collaborators, and the messy reality of creation. Transparency itself may become a form of artistic credibility. In a world flooded with synthetic content, proof of humanity becomes part of the art.

Finally, musicians must remember that artistry has never been solely about efficiency. The value of music is not that it can be generated quickly. Its value lies precisely in the fact that it costs something human to make. The hours of practice, failed rehearsals, emotional vulnerability, technical discipline, and personal sacrifice are not obstacles to art. They are the very reason art matters.

I do not celebrate the rise of AI-generated artists on the charts. As a musician, educator, conductor, and scholar, it pains me to watch music increasingly treated as disposable content rather than human expression. But I also believe this moment presents an opportunity. The more synthetic our culture becomes, the more audiences may hunger for authenticity. And when that happens, the musicians who can stand on a stage, look an audience in the eye, embrace the unpredictability of live performance, and create something unmistakably human will become more valuable than ever.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

No, Martin Luther Didn’t Rip Off Drinking Songs

May 14, 2026 by Clay

One of the most repeated claims in popular church music discussions is the assertion that “many old hymns were originally bar songs” or that the church intentionally borrowed tunes from taverns and pubs in order to make worship music more familiar to ordinary people. The statement is appealing because it sounds rebellious, clever, and historically grounded. It is frequently repeated in sermons, church music workshops, and online debates as a defense for contemporary worship styles. Yet the historical evidence for this sweeping claim is remarkably thin. While a small number of hymn tunes may have connections to secular melodies, the broad narrative that churches routinely adopted drinking songs for congregational worship is largely a myth.

Part of the confusion comes from the way music functioned in earlier centuries. Before recordings, radio, or commercial copyright systems, melodies circulated freely among many different social settings. A tune might appear in a folk song, a dance collection, a theatrical work, and later in a sacred text. This does not necessarily mean the church “borrowed” a tavern song. In many cases, the tune already existed in broader musical culture long before it appeared in either a church or a pub. Folk melodies were communal property, not the exclusive possession of any one setting or institution. The English tune GREENSLEEVES (from approximately 1580), now commonly associated with the Christmas carol What Child Is This? (text from 1865), demonstrates this kind of circulation. Long before its later sacred association, the melody appeared widely in instrumental collections, ballad traditions, and popular secular settings throughout England. Its history reflects the fluid movement of melodies across society rather than a deliberate effort by the church to adopt bar music.

The claim also misunderstands the chronology of many famous hymn tunes. Some melodies now accused of being “bar songs” were actually composed for sacred or formal use first. Over time, popular culture adopted and reused these tunes in secular contexts because they were memorable and widely known. In other words, the movement of music often flowed from church to society rather than from tavern to sanctuary. This pattern was especially common in Europe and early America, where churches were among the largest and most influential musical institutions in public life. The tune OLD HUNDREDTH, now most closely associated with the Doxology, is a prime example. Originally connected to the Genevan Psalter of the sixteenth century, the melody emerged from a distinctly sacred Reformed tradition before later appearing in civic ceremonies, patriotic settings, educational contexts, and public culture far beyond the walls of the church.

One figure often pulled into this discussion is Martin Luther. It is frequently claimed that Luther took drinking songs and turned them into hymns of the Protestant Reformation. Historians, however, have found little evidence for this accusation. Luther certainly encouraged congregational singing and occasionally adapted existing melodies, but most of the tunes associated with his hymns were either newly composed, drawn from sacred chant traditions, or adapted from respectable folk music rather than tavern music. The charge that Luther filled the church with drinking songs appears to have originated more from later critics than from documented historical practice.

Similarly, the Wesleyan revival in eighteenth-century England is often cited as another example of pub melodies entering the church. Yet Charles Wesley and John Wesley generally paired their hymn texts with established sacred tunes or newly composed melodies intended for worship. While Methodism embraced accessible music and vigorous congregational participation, there is little evidence that the Wesleys intentionally raided taverns for melodies. In fact, many early Methodist leaders were deeply concerned about maintaining moral and spiritual seriousness in worship music.

Another source of misunderstanding lies in the term “secular.” Modern listeners often imagine a sharp divide between sacred and secular music, but earlier societies did not always organize music in that way. A melody used for a folk dance could later appear in a sacred anthem without scandal because tunes themselves were not considered morally fixed objects. The moral meaning of music was shaped more by its text, context, and performance than by the melody alone. Thus, the occasional overlap between sacred and secular repertories should not be interpreted as deliberate attempts to smuggle drinking culture into worship.

Ironically, there is strong evidence that taverns, theaters, and popular entertainment venues frequently borrowed from church music because hymns were among the most familiar melodies in society. Congregational singing gave people a shared musical vocabulary. A tune learned in church on Sunday could easily reappear in political songs, patriotic music, folk ballads, or comedic stage productions during the week. This direction of influence is often ignored in modern retellings of the “bar song hymn” myth because it disrupts the more dramatic narrative that churches succeeded by imitating popular culture.

The persistence of this myth today often reveals more about current debates than about historical reality. The story is commonly used to justify stylistic innovation in worship by suggesting that the church has always copied popular music trends. Yet history is more nuanced. Churches throughout the centuries have certainly adapted musical languages familiar to their communities, but they have also cultivated distinct musical traditions meant to elevate worship and support theology. Sacred music has never been merely an imitation of entertainment culture.

Ultimately, the history of hymnody is far richer and more complex than the simplistic claim that “old hymns were once pub songs.” A few isolated examples of crossover certainly exist, as they do in nearly every musical tradition. However, the widespread assertion that churches routinely pulled melodies out of bars in order to attract worshippers is historically exaggerated and often backwards. In many cases, it was secular culture that borrowed from the church’s music, not the other way around. Understanding this distinction allows for a more honest and historically grounded conversation about worship, tradition, and the evolving role of music in the life of the church.


Recommended Reading

Filed Under: Uncategorized

Rubén González

April 13, 2026 by Clay

Rubén González stands as one of the most elegant and influential pianists in the history of Afro-Cuban jazz. Known for his lyrical touch, rhythmic sophistication, and deep connection to traditional Cuban forms such as son, danzón, and mambo, González helped shape a piano style that bridged classical technique with street-level musical intuition. Though he spent decades performing in Cuba’s golden era of dance orchestras, his international recognition arrived later in life, introducing global audiences to the richness of Afro-Cuban musical heritage through his expressive and understated artistry.

Born in Santa Clara, Cuba, in 1919, González trained as a classical pianist before gravitating toward popular Cuban music. His work with major Cuban ensembles in the mid-twentieth century helped define the piano’s evolving role in Afro-Cuban jazz, particularly in its blending of syncopated montuno patterns with harmonic sophistication. González’s style was distinctive for its balance between rhythmic drive and melodic clarity, allowing him to accompany singers and instrumentalists while also standing out as a compelling solo voice.

Despite his stature within Cuban musical circles, González spent years outside the international spotlight after the decline of Havana’s nightlife scene in the early 1960s. By the 1990s, however, his rediscovery became one of the most remarkable musical revivals of the century. Encouraged to return to the piano after a period of relative inactivity, he demonstrated that his artistry had lost none of its warmth, agility, or emotional depth.

This resurgence culminated in his participation in the Buena Vista Social Club project, which brought together veteran Cuban musicians whose careers had flourished before the Cuban Revolution. González’s piano playing became one of the defining elements of the ensemble’s sound. His gentle yet rhythmically grounded approach supported singers and instrumentalists alike, creating a musical atmosphere that felt both intimate and timeless. His performances captured the elegance of pre-revolutionary Cuban dance halls while introducing new listeners to the expressive power of traditional son-based arrangements.

The international success of the Buena Vista Social Club recording and subsequent performances owed much to the involvement of American guitarist and producer Ry Cooder. Cooder helped assemble the group, facilitated the recording sessions in Havana, and played a key role in bringing these musicians to worldwide attention. Rather than overshadowing the Cuban artists, his work emphasized authenticity and respect for their traditions, allowing performers like González to shine on their own terms. The project became both a preservation effort and a cultural bridge, connecting generations and continents through shared musical appreciation.

My own introduction to the Buena Vista Social Club came unexpectedly during my high school Spanish I class with my teacher, Carrie Witter. Her decision to incorporate Cuban music into the classroom opened a door that traditional language exercises never could. Listening to these recordings gave me a sense of cultural immersion that helped make the language come alive, and it is no exaggeration to say that this musical exposure played a meaningful role in helping me successfully complete the course. More importantly, it sparked a lasting appreciation for Cuban music that continues today.

That early encounter with the music became even more meaningful years later when I had the opportunity to visit Havana in 2018 while working on the Carnival Paradise. Walking through the streets of the city whose musical traditions had produced artists like Rubén González felt like stepping into the living context behind the recordings I had first heard in the classroom. The rhythms, architecture, and atmosphere reinforced how deeply place and culture shape musical expression and deepened my appreciation for the musical legacy preserved in the Buena Vista Social Club recordings.

Rubén González’s legacy endures not only through his recordings but through the renewed global interest in Afro-Cuban jazz that the Buena Vista Social Club project helped inspire. One example of his continuing influence in my own teaching is that his piece “Mandinga” has been included in the required listening for the MUS 112A Group Piano class at Cochise College since I began teaching the course in January. Introducing students to González’s playing in this way helps connect them with authentic Afro-Cuban piano style while reinforcing the historical importance of his work. For listeners and students alike, his music represents both a personal musical discovery and a connection to a broader story of preservation, collaboration, and cultural celebration.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

On Air with The Choral Tradition

April 12, 2026 by Clay

This interview aired on Public Radio East on Sunday, April 12, 2026.

Recently, I had the pleasure of joining host Finley Woolston on The Choral Tradition, broadcast on Public Radio East’s Classical Station, for a conversation about choral music and the many ways it connects singers and listeners across traditions, seasons, and communities.

During the program, we explored a selection of recordings that highlight both sacred repertoire and expressive contemporary arranging, featuring ensembles and singers from my work with the University of Arizona and the Tucson Interfaith Choir and Orchestra:

• I Walked Today Where Jesus Walked (arr. Brandon Stewart), Tucson Interfaith Choir
• Winter by Tori Amos (arr. Fiona Lander), University of Arizona Treble Glee, with Jazz Caley and Kieryn Zizzo, soloists
• Ave verum corpus by William Byrd, University of Arizona Recital Choir
• Abendlied by Felix Mendelssohn, University of Arizona Treble Glee
• Kiddush by Kurt Weill, University of Arizona Recital Choir, with Dane Carten, soloist

Together, these selections reflect a wide expressive landscape including pilgrimage and devotion, memory and stillness, Renaissance clarity, Romantic warmth, and the rich cultural voice of twentieth century sacred art song. It was a joy to share the stories behind these pieces and the ensembles who brought them to life.

I am grateful to Finley Woolston and the team at Public Radio East for the opportunity to talk about this music and the communities that make it possible. I hope you enjoy listening to the conversation as much as I enjoyed being part of it.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

He Is Not Here. He Is Risen.

March 8, 2026 by Clay

As we approach the Resurrection in Lamb of God, it is worth remembering that this moment has been prepared for musically from the very beginning.

One of the most profound compositional decisions in this oratorio is the use of the solo cello as the voice of Jesus. Jesus is represented instrumentally rather than with a solo voice like the rest of the characters in this setting of the story. His “voice” is melodic, lyrical, and intimate. It weaves through scenes, sometimes beneath the choir, sometimes emerging with clarity, and sometimes almost hidden.

Before we ever reach the Resurrection, we have learned to recognize Him by sound.

The cello often enters with a warm, singing tone, expressive and almost vocal in quality. It doesn’t dominate. It invites. It pleads. It comforts. In Gethsemane, it feels heavy and yearning. In moments of teaching, it feels steady and compassionate. At the Crucifixion, it becomes strained, exposed, and almost fragile.

And then, after “It is finished,” the cello stops.

That absence is one of the most powerful musical moments in the entire work.
There is no dramatic announcement. No orchestral explosion.
Just absence.

And that absence mirrors the theological reality of Holy Saturday:
the silence of heaven, the confusion of disciples, the ache of grief.

It is in that silence that we enter the Resurrection narrative.

And who enters first?

The women.

In the Gospels, particularly Luke 24, we read: 
“Why seek ye the living among the dead? He is not here, but is risen.”

In the oratorio, when the choir sings this text, Antha mana bakya anti? (Woman, why weepest thou?), notice the musical shift. The harmony brightens. There is lift. There is vertical space. Rhythms become more energized. The orchestration opens up. It feels like light entering a sealed room. There is hope.

But what I love is that the Resurrection in this work does not begin with triumph. It begins with devotion.

The women come to the tomb not expecting a miracle, but intending to finish a burial.

They come with spices, with love, and with grief.

And heaven entrusts them with the first proclamation of Easter.

That is not incidental.

In a first century world where women’s testimony was not legally valid in many settings, God chooses them as the first witnesses of the most important event in human history.

The first Resurrection sermon was preached to women.

In Gardner’s setting, that truth is amplified by texture. Often, the women’s voices are clear, present, and emotionally forward. There is vulnerability in the lines. The music allows space for sorrow before it moves into revelation.

Then we come to one of the most intimate scenes in the entire oratorio:
Mary at the tomb.

She is weeping.

The music reflects that grief. Harmonies may feel suspended. Phrases may feel unresolved. There is a sense of searching. The orchestra supports but does not overwhelm. It feels small, personal, and almost fragile.

And then the cello returns.

Not with fanfare.

Not with brass.

Not with percussion.

The voice of Jesus comes back the same way He ministered throughout the work: personally.

When Christ says, “Mary,” the music does not shout. It recognizes.

The cello line is often lyrical and direct. It does not argue. It does not defend. It simply calls. And Mary knows that sound.

That moment teaches us something profound about Resurrection theology.

The Resurrection was not first revealed through spectacle, but through relationship.

Jesus could have appeared first to Pilate, to Caiaphas, or to Rome.

Instead, He appears to a grieving woman in a garden.

Musically, Gardner reinforces that intimacy. The cello line feels familiar. It is the same voice we have heard all along. The same melodic identity. The same timbre. The same heart.

The Resurrection is not the introduction of a new Christ.

It is the return of the same Christ, alive.

For us as performers, that continuity matters. When the cello returns, the audience may not consciously think, “Ah, the thematic motif has reappeared.” But they feel it. They recognize it.

Just like Mary did.

There is also something beautiful in how the choir functions in the Resurrection. Earlier in the work, the choir can represent crowds, sometimes faithful and sometimes hostile. They cry “Hosanna.” They cry “Crucify Him.”

But in the Resurrection, the choral sound often becomes unified proclamation.
No longer divided. No longer chaotic.

“He is risen.”

The music itself feels reconciled.

Another subtle but powerful aspect is harmonic resolution. Throughout the Passion narrative, we feel tension: minor tonalities, suspensions that delay resolution, melodic lines that ache. In the Resurrection, those tensions begin to release. Cadences feel earned. Light breaks through harmonically.

It is as if the music itself has been holding its breath and finally…exhales.

Let’s return to the women for a moment.

Mary Magdalene becomes, in many Christian traditions, the “apostle to the apostles,” the one sent to tell the others.

What does she carry?

Not just information.

But encounter.

She does not say, “The angel told me something interesting.”

She says, “I have seen the Lord.”

As we rehearse this section, we are not simply preparing notes and rhythms. We are stepping into that same role.

We become witnesses.

The cello may represent Christ’s voice, but the choir and orchestra represent those who respond to it, those who carry it forward.

Here is what moves me most:

Mary heard Him because she lingered.

She stayed when others left.

She wept. She searched. She remained.

And in that lingering, she recognized His voice.

As musicians, we are invited to linger as well.

To not rush the phrasing.

To not gloss over the silence.

To let the absence after the Crucifixion truly feel empty.

To let the return of the cello truly feel like breath returning to a body.

If we allow ourselves to experience that arc, not just technically but spiritually, then when we perform it, the audience will not just hear music.

They will feel Resurrection.

The women at the tomb teach us that devotion precedes revelation.

The cello teaches us that Christ’s voice is consistent, even through death.

And the Resurrection teaches us that silence is not the end of the story.

“He is not here, but is risen.”

May we play and sing in a way that helps others recognize His voice when it returns.


This devotional was offered at the Lamb of God (TICAO) choral rehearsal on Sunday, March 8, 2026, International Women’s Day.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

The Worship Wars We Inherited

February 4, 2026 by Clay

The distinction between “traditional” and “contemporary” music in the church is often presented as self-evident, as though these categories were timeless, objective, and universally agreed upon. In practice, however, the line between traditional and contemporary worship music is remarkably fluid. What one generation experiences as new, disruptive, or innovative is frequently absorbed by the next generation as familiar, stable, and even sacred. The debate, therefore, is less about music itself and more about memory, identity, and cultural comfort.

At its core, the traditional and contemporary divide is arbitrary. It does not arise from any clear theological boundary, nor from a consistent musical definition. Instead, it reflects shifting cultural norms, generational attachments, and unspoken assumptions about what “church music” is supposed to sound like. These assumptions often harden into labels that obscure the living, evolving nature of worship.

I was reminded of this arbitrariness a few months ago when we held a hymn-sing service at our church. We invited the congregation to submit hymn requests on index cards so that we could locate the music and project it for communal singing. Many of the cards listed specific hymn titles, often accompanied by a brief note explaining why a particular song mattered to the writer. One card, however, stood out. It was submitted anonymously and contained only two words, written in thick, blue marker and all capital letters: “TRADITIONAL MUSIC.” The letters were pressed hard into the card, and there was a faint but unmistakable edge of frustration in its tone. No titles were named, no explanation offered, just an insistence on a category, as though its meaning were obvious and universally shared. In that moment, it became clear that the traditional versus contemporary debate is rarely about repertoire alone, but about deeper questions of identity, comfort, and belonging.

One of the clearest examples of this arbitrariness is the way Gaither hymns from the 1970s and 1980s are now routinely grouped under the label “traditional.” Songs such as Because He Lives or He Touched Me were once unmistakably contemporary. They emerged from a revivalist, folk-influenced idiom that contrasted sharply with the metrical hymns of earlier centuries. Their harmonic language, emotional directness, and popular musical style initially set them apart from what many churches considered acceptable worship music.

Yet over time, these songs became familiar. Congregations learned them by heart, sang them at funerals and baptisms, and associated them with deeply meaningful moments of faith. As new musical styles entered the church, including praise bands, pop-rock worship songs, and electronic textures, the Gaither repertoire quietly migrated across the boundary into the category of “traditional.” Nothing about the music itself changed. Only the cultural context did.

This pattern is not new. One of the most beloved hymns in Christian history, Amazing Grace, was itself once a contemporary composition. When John Newton wrote it in the late eighteenth century, it did not yet have its now-famous tune and was part of a growing movement of evangelical hymnody that emphasized personal experience, emotional expression, and accessible language. This was a departure from older psalm-singing traditions that dominated earlier Protestant worship.

To many in Newton’s time, hymns like Amazing Grace represented innovation. They reflected theological and musical shifts tied to revival movements and changing social conditions. Today, however, the hymn is often held up as the epitome of “traditional” worship, so much so that its status as once-new is almost unthinkable to many churchgoers.

This example reveals an important truth. “Traditional” is not a fixed category. It is a moving target, defined retrospectively. Music becomes traditional not because of its age alone, but because it has been received, repeated, and woven into communal memory. What matters most is not when a piece was written, but whether it has become a shared language of worship.

Another layer of complexity arises when we consider geography and culture. What counts as traditional worship music in one context may sound entirely contemporary, or even foreign, in another. A pipe organ chorale might feel deeply traditional in a Midwestern mainline Protestant church, while it may feel unfamiliar or distant in a congregation shaped by gospel, global song, or oral traditions.

Likewise, musical forms rooted in African American worship, such as spirituals or gospel hymns, have often been labeled “contemporary” or “special music” in predominantly white congregations, despite having histories as long and venerable as European hymnody. These labels reveal less about the music and more about whose culture has been normalized as “tradition.”

This cultural lens helps explain why stylistic judgments are often mistaken for theological ones. When churches argue over traditional versus contemporary music, they are frequently negotiating questions of identity, belonging, and power rather than doctrine. Musical preference becomes a proxy for deeper anxieties about change, continuity, and generational influence.

A striking illustration of this dynamic can be found in the inclusion of Duke Ellington’s Come Sunday in the United Methodist Hymnal. Composed in the early 1960s as part of Ellington’s Sacred Concerts, Come Sunday emerged from the world of jazz, a genre once considered entirely unsuitable for worship in many mainline churches. Jazz, after all, was associated with nightclubs, improvisation, and cultural spaces outside ecclesial control.

And yet, Come Sunday now appears in a denominational hymnal and is often performed in settings that are explicitly labeled “traditional worship.” Sung with choir, organ, or piano, it functions liturgically in much the same way as older hymns. Its text is prayerful, its melody reverent, and its theological content unmistakably Christian.

The acceptance of Come Sunday exposes the weakness of rigid stylistic categories. Though composed in the twentieth century and rooted in a distinctly American musical idiom, it has been received as a legitimate and even dignified expression of worship. Its “traditional” status emerges not from its origin but from its adoption.

This example also highlights how tradition itself is formed. Tradition is not merely inherited. It is curated. Hymnals, worship planners, pastors, and congregations actively decide what to carry forward. In doing so, they transform once-new music into shared heritage.

Recognizing this process can free the church from unproductive binaries. Instead of asking whether a piece of music is traditional or contemporary, we might ask different questions. Does this music help the congregation pray? Does it speak truthfully about God and the human condition? Does it invite participation rather than performance?

Such questions move the conversation away from taste and toward purpose. They acknowledge that worship music has always evolved, drawing from the musical languages of its time while being shaped by theological reflection and communal discernment.

When we remember that today’s contemporary worship songs may one day be sung with the same reverence as Amazing Grace, humility becomes possible. We are reminded that we are stewards, not gatekeepers, of the church’s song.

Ultimately, the traditional and contemporary divide tells us more about ourselves than about the music we sing. By recognizing its arbitrariness, the church can reclaim a richer, more generous understanding of tradition, one that honors the past, engages the present, and remains open to the future.

Filed Under: Uncategorized

  • Page 1
  • Page 2
  • Go to Next Page »

© 2026 · Clay Whittington Music & Entertainment